Part 4 – The Room We Misunderstood
At p.m., Bianca entered the bedroom hallway.
She was wearing the same dark coat she had worn in the corridor footage, and she carried a small paper bag in one hand.
The image was gray and grainy, but Xavier recognized her immediately.
She glanced toward the penthouse door, then knocked once on the bedroom door before opening it.
A moment later, Dex appeared behind her.
Xavier leaned closer to the screen.
The footage showed no sound, only the careful movements of people who believed the hallway was empty.
Bianca set the paper bag on the console table.
Dex spoke to her, his face turned partly away from the camera.
She answered with a brief shake of her head, then stepped into the bedroom.
Dex remained outside.
For nearly a minute, he stood motionless in the hall, watching the door.
Then he went in too.
The recording ended after several minutes of blurred movement and a sudden shift in the camera’s angle.
Xavier sat back.
It established that Dex had entered the bedroom after Bianca, but it did not explain why.
It didn’t show Phoebe arriving.
It didn’t show whether the scene she had heard was staged, accidental, or something else.
And it didn’t tell him why Dex had removed the original footage.
He called Niko.
“Can the audio be recovered?”
“The unit had a microphone, but the sound file is damaged,” Niko replied. “Sal thinks he can repair part of it.”
“How long?”
“An hour, maybe more.”
“Keep working on it.”
Xavier ended the call and watched the clip again.
At first, he noticed only the details he had already seen: Bianca’s arrival, Dex’s careful pause, the bedroom door closing.
Then he saw the paper bag.
The logo on its side was faint but familiar.
It belonged to a small bakery several blocks from the penthouse, one Xavier had used for private meetings because its owner knew how to keep a room quiet.
He called the bakery.
The owner remembered the order.
Bianca had picked it up that afternoon, but the order had been placed under Dex’s name.
“What did he order?” Xavier asked.
“Coffee, two glasses of wine, and a box of pastries,” the owner said. “He asked me to put the wine in a paper bag.”
Xavier thanked him and ended the call.
The wine in the hallway had not been left there by Bianca.
Dex had arranged it.
The thought did not make the scene innocent.
It made it deliberate.
He called Phoebe.
“I recovered part of the old hallway footage,” he said. “It shows Bianca entering the bedroom, then Dex arriving shortly afterward.”
“Does it show anything else?”
“Not yet.”
“Could you send it to me?”
“I’ll have Niko send you the unedited file.”
There was a pause.
“Xavier, I don’t want you to tell me what you think it means before I see it.”
“I won’t.”
“Thank you.”
“And I found out the wine was ordered by Dex.”
Her breath changed slightly.
“Not Bianca?”
“The bakery confirmed it was his order.”
“Does that mean he arranged for her to be there?”
“I don’t know.”
“Then don’t turn it into an answer.”
“I won’t.”
He heard the twins making soft sounds in the background, then Phoebe’s quiet voice soothing one of them.
“I’m going to show it to Mara,” she said. “We’ll watch it together.”
“All right.”
“I’ll call you afterward.”
“I’ll wait.”
The call ended.
Xavier sent the footage and the bakery details to Niko, asking him to forward everything directly to Phoebe.
Then he sat alone in the security office, trying to understand what kind of man he had become in the months before Phoebe left.
He had told himself that keeping a narrow circle of trusted people was necessary.
He had told himself that Dex was capable, discreet, and loyal.
He had not asked what it meant to place that much power in one man’s hands.
The mistake had not been a single missed letter or an unreturned call.
It had been the comfort of not having to look.
At home, Phoebe watched the clip with Mara after putting the twins down for their nap.
The image was small on her laptop, the hallway camera’s view narrowed by the old lens.
Still, she saw Bianca clearly enough.
“Pause it,” Mara said.
Phoebe stopped the footage as Bianca stepped through the bedroom door.
Mara studied the still.
“She looks tense.”
“She looks like she’s checking whether someone’s watching.”
“Maybe she was.”
Phoebe pressed play.
Dex entered the frame.
He looked toward the camera before going inside.
The moment was so brief that Phoebe almost missed it, but she rewound the clip and watched again.
“He looks right at it,” she said.
Mara leaned closer.
“Do you think he knew it was there?”
“He was the person who managed the security system.”
They watched him enter the bedroom.
The footage stopped before anything could be understood.
Phoebe stared at the frozen image.
For months, she had remembered a pair of red heels outside the bedroom and the sound of Bianca laughing behind the door.
Her mind had filled in the rest because the facts she had were painful and incomplete.
She had left without opening the door.
It had been the only choice she could make in that moment without losing the last of her composure.
The video did not make her foolish for believing what she had heard.
It did not make her decision a mistake.
It only made the memory less certain.
Mara placed a hand over Phoebe’s.
“You can still be hurt by what you heard, even if there was more happening.”
“I know.”
“Do you believe Bianca?”
“I believe she was there.”
“And Dex?”
“I don’t know.”
Phoebe closed the laptop.
“Xavier sent the footage before I asked twice.”
“That matters.”
“It does.”
“Does it make you trust him?”
“It makes me notice what he’s doing.”
Mara’s hand stayed over hers.
“That’s enough for now.”
Phoebe called Xavier after the twins woke.
“I watched it,” she said.
“What did you think?”
“That Bianca looked uncomfortable.”
“I saw that too.”
“Dex looked at the camera.”
“I noticed.”
“Did the team tell you whether he knew about that old unit?”
“He managed the security system. I’m sure he knew it existed.”
“Then he knew the footage might be there.”
“Yes.”
“And he still took the original footage.”
“Yes.”
Neither of them spoke for a few seconds.
“Did Bianca know he was being recorded?” Phoebe asked.
“I don’t know.”
“Did she know the wine was staged?”
“I don’t know.”
“Did she know he was going to be there?”
“I don’t know.”
There was no easy reassurance in his voice, no attempt to use uncertainty as a way to steer her toward the answer he preferred.
Phoebe rested her forehead against the kitchen cabinet.
“I’m so tired of not knowing.”
“I know.”
“You don’t know what it was like to hear her in our room.”
“No,” Xavier said. “I don’t.”
“You don’t know what it was like to go home alone with a suitcase and realize I was already pregnant.”
“I don’t.”
“And I don’t know what you were told.”
His reply came gently.
“We’re both learning what the other person had to live with.”
“That isn’t forgiveness.”
“No.”
“Good.”
“I’m not asking for it.”
After the call, Xavier waited for the restored audio.
Niko arrived with Sal shortly after dusk.
Sal carried a small drive in a padded case and set it on the desk.
“I recovered a portion of the sound,” he said. “It’s incomplete, and there are gaps.”
“Is it usable?”
“Some of it.”
Xavier nodded to Niko.
The first sounds were soft and indistinct: footsteps, a door, the faint clink of glass.
Then Bianca’s voice came through, thin but recognizable.
“I don’t think he’ll come.”
Dex answered.
“He will if he knows you’re here.”
“I don’t want Phoebe walking into this.”
There was a pause.
“You said she’d be at the hospital,” Bianca continued.
“She was meant to be.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“It’s the best one I have.”
Xavier’s hands tightened against the desk.
The recording crackled.
Then came Dex’s voice again.
“Leave the shoes outside. The wine stays here.”
“Why?”
“Because a person who believes she’s being replaced will stop asking questions and get out.”
A few seconds of silence followed.
Bianca’s voice turned sharp.
“You said you wanted her safe.”
“I do.”
“That is not the same as making her hate him.”
“It keeps her away from the building.”
“And when she finds out?”
“She won’t.”
The file broke into static.
Xavier sat perfectly still.
Niko looked at the screen, then at him.
“I can try to clean up the missing section.”
“Do it.”
Sal removed his headphones.
“Mr. Dion, I should tell you the recovered audio may not be a complete record. There could be context before and after.”
“I understand.”
But he had heard enough to know that the red heels and the wine had not appeared by chance.
He called Phoebe.
The call rang twice.
“Did you recover it?” she asked.
“Yes.”
“What did you hear?”
He could have sent the file first.
He could have waited until Niko cleaned the rest.
Instead, he said, “I heard Dex tell Bianca to leave her shoes outside and leave the wine in the bedroom.”
Phoebe was silent.
“He said it would make you think he had replaced you,” Xavier continued. “He said you would stop asking questions and leave.”
The silence grew, then changed into a quiet breath.
“Did Bianca agree?”
“She asked why.”
“And?”
“Dex told her he wanted you safe.”
Phoebe did not speak.
Xavier waited.
“Do you believe that?” she asked at last.
“I don’t know.”
“Does he say what danger?”
“Not in the section I heard.”
“Then send me the whole file.”
“I will.”
“Not a cleaned-up version.”
“The original recovered file and a copy of the restoration.”
“All right.”
He heard her shift the phone.
“I have to go. Liam’s awake.”
“Of course.”
“Xavier?”
“Yes?”
“Don’t decide that the way he did it makes the reason acceptable.”
“I won’t.”
She ended the call.
Xavier sent the files before the technician had finished cleaning the remaining audio.
He did not ask how Phoebe reacted.
He sat at the desk until Niko returned with a message from the team.
“We found Dex,” Niko said.
Xavier looked up.
“Where?”
“Near Milwaukee. He contacted an attorney and agreed to speak with us. He says he’ll cooperate if the interview is handled through counsel.”
“Is he safe?”
“He says he is.”
“Bring him in only with the authorities present. No private meeting.”
Niko studied him for a moment.
“That’s different from what you would have asked for before.”
“Yes,” Xavier said. “It is.”
Dex arrived the next day with his attorney and a representative from the security company.
He looked older than Xavier remembered, though only a few weeks had passed.
His suit was neat, his face composed, and his hands rested on the table as if he had practiced keeping them still.
Xavier sat across from him.
A recorder was placed between them.
“I removed the original footage,” Dex said before anyone asked. “I did it because I didn’t want you to see it.”
“You staged the scene in the bedroom.”
Dex glanced toward the recorder.
“I arranged Bianca’s visit.”
“You ordered the wine.”
“Yes.”
“You told her to leave her shoes outside.”
“Yes.”
“You wanted Phoebe to believe she had walked in on an affair.”
Dex swallowed.
“I wanted her to leave the penthouse.”
“You knew what that would do to her.”
“I knew it would hurt.”
Xavier leaned back.
“Then don’t call it protection.”
Dex lowered his eyes.
“I didn’t know how else to get her out.”
“That isn’t a reason. It’s a description of what you chose.”
“I know.”
“Why did you want her gone?”
For the first time, Dex looked directly at him.
“Because someone had learned the building’s routines.”
The room became still.
“Who?” Xavier asked.
“I don’t know his real name.”
“Then tell us what you do know.”
The attorney placed a hand on the table, a quiet reminder that Dex’s answers would be recorded and could have consequences.
Dex nodded.
“A man approached me several months before Phoebe left. He said he worked for a private intelligence firm and wanted details about the people who came and went from the penthouse.”
“Did you give him anything?”
“At first, I thought he was trying to identify a leak in the building. He knew things about the old security systems and the service entrances. He offered to pay for information.”
“And you accepted?”
“I told myself I was learning what he knew.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“I gave him the schedule for the evening staff. Then I gave him the times you usually left for the office.”
Xavier’s face hardened, but he kept his voice even.
“What did he do with it?”
“I don’t know.”
“You told him when my wife was home.”
“I didn’t give him Phoebe’s schedule at first.”
“But you knew he had information about the building.”
“Yes.”
“And you continued speaking with him.”
“Yes.”
Dex stared at the recorder.
“When I realized he was learning the household’s routines, I told him I was done. He said he already knew enough to cause trouble if I stopped helping.”
“What kind of trouble?”
“He mentioned the penthouse. He mentioned Phoebe.”
“Did he threaten her?”
“Not directly.”
“Did you tell anyone?”
“No.”
“Why?”
“I thought I could handle it.”
The answer sounded too familiar.
It was the same confidence Xavier had used to justify giving Dex control over his calls and correspondence.
It was the same refusal to ask another person to share responsibility.
“Then you decided the safest way to protect Phoebe was to make her think I had betrayed her,” Xavier said.
Dex’s eyes flicked up.
“Yes.”
“You decided for her.”
“Yes.”
“You decided for me.”
“Yes.”
“And afterward, you intercepted her messages.”
“I didn’t want her coming back.”
“Why?”
“Because if she came back, the man could use her to get close to you.”
“Did he know she had left?”
“I told him she was no longer in the building.”
“What did he say?”
“He said that was better.”
The room seemed colder.
Xavier thought of Phoebe alone with a suitcase, then alone through the pregnancy, alone at the hospital while the babies fought to grow strong enough to come home.
Dex had not protected her from danger.
He had removed her from Xavier’s reach and then called the isolation safety.
“What did Bianca know?” Xavier asked.
“She knew I had brought her there to warn me.”
“Warn you about what?”
“An unknown man had asked her questions at the gala.”
“Why didn’t she tell me directly?”
“She thought she’d be overheard. She gave me the details, and I told her you would speak with her privately.”
“You never arranged that conversation.”
“No.”
“You put her in the bedroom and made Phoebe believe she was my lover.”
“Yes.”
“Did you tell Bianca you were staging an affair?”
“No. I told her to leave the shoes outside because I wanted people to think she’d arrived unexpectedly. I told her the wine was part of a conversation. I didn’t tell her Phoebe was likely to come home.”
Dex’s attorney shifted in his chair.
Xavier kept his attention on Dex.
“Did Bianca know you planned to keep my wife away from me?”
“Not then.”
“And the letters?”
“I intercepted them.”
“Every one?”
“Yes.”
“The hospital notices?”
Dex pressed his lips together.
“Some came through the house. Some came through the private security address.”
“How many?”
“All of them.”
Xavier felt the words settle inside him, heavy and precise.
“Did you know Phoebe was pregnant?”
“Yes.”
“Did you know she was having twins?”
“I learned when the hospital sent the first notice.”
“And you kept it from me.”
“Yes.”
“Did you think that was protecting her?”
“No.”
“What did you think it was?”
Dex looked exhausted.
“I thought the longer you stayed apart, the less likely the man would use her to reach you.”
“You could have told me the threat existed.”
“I thought you’d go after him.”
“I might have.”
“You would have.”
“Then you should have trusted me enough to say what was happening.”
Dex’s expression tightened.
“I knew what you would do.”
“You knew what I might do. You didn’t know what I would choose, because you never let me choose.”
For the first time, Dex seemed to lose his practiced composure.
“I was trying to prevent another war.”
“And you built one inside my home.”
Dex lowered his head.
“I know.”
The recorder continued to run.
Xavier looked at the attorney.
“We have enough for today.”
The interview ended with the authorities receiving the recovered footage and Dex’s statement.
No one threatened him, and no one promised him anything.
He was escorted away through the front entrance with his attorney, leaving Xavier in the conference room with the recorder and a glass of water he had not touched.
Phoebe came to the penthouse that evening with Mara.
She had wanted the full statement before deciding whether she could face him.
Now she stood in the security office, the twins at home with their aunt and a sitter, and listened to the recovered audio with Xavier beside her.
When Dex’s voice said, Leave the shoes outside, Phoebe closed her eyes.
When he said that a person who believed she was being replaced would leave, she lowered her chin.
The words did not surprise her anymore.
That did not make them hurt less.
“I thought she was laughing with him,” she said.
“She was.”
“He wanted me to hear it.”
“Yes.”
“He wanted me to think the worst of you.”
“Yes.”
Phoebe stood very still.
“And you still don’t know why he believed keeping me away was worth letting me think you had betrayed me.”
“I know why he says he did it.”
“That isn’t the same.”
“No.”
She opened her eyes and looked at the frozen image on the screen.
Bianca stood in the hallway, one hand on the bedroom door.
Dex was several paces behind her.
“What did Bianca know about the man who approached her?” Phoebe asked.
“She says he asked about the building’s routines and who attended the penthouse events.”
“Did she know he was dangerous?”
“She says she suspected he was connected to a group that wanted access to you and me.”
“Did you believe her?”
“I believed she was frightened.”
“That’s not the same thing as believing every detail.”
“No.”
Phoebe moved toward the desk.
She did not touch the screen.
“I don’t know what I’m supposed to feel about her.”
“You don’t have to decide.”
“I don’t know what I’m supposed to feel about you.”
“You don’t have to decide that either.”
Her eyes met his.
“I left because I thought you were with her.”
“I know.”
“No. You know the sentence. You don’t know the moment.”
Xavier lowered his gaze.
“You’re right.”
“I stood outside that door and heard her laugh. I saw those shoes. I was so tired of trying to make excuses for things that hurt me.”
“I understand.”
“You don’t have to tell me you understand.”
“I’m sorry.”
She turned away from the screen.
“I want to see the rest of the evidence.”
“You will.”
“Every part of it.”
“Yes.”
“And I want the authorities involved from here on. No private arrangements, no deciding that my ignorance is safer.”
“I agree.”
She studied him for a long moment.
Then she nodded, once.
It was not forgiveness.
It was agreement about what came next.
At home, Ivy was awake when Phoebe returned.
She lifted her from the crib and held her close, feeling the baby’s warm cheek against her shoulder.
Mara waited in the kitchen.
“Did you learn the truth?” she asked.
“I learned why Dex staged the room.”
“And?”
“He was trying to keep me away from Xavier because someone had learned the building’s routines.”
“Do you believe that?”
“I believe Dex was afraid.”
“Of Xavier?”
“Of the man he had been talking to.”
Mara’s face tightened.
“Did he give the man information?”
“He did.”
“How much?”
“Enough to help him learn when the penthouse was occupied.”
Mara looked toward the twins’ room.
“Were the children in danger?”
“Not according to what we know.”
“Phoebe.”
“We don’t know.”
The honest answer sat between them.
Phoebe looked down at Ivy, who had fallen asleep against her shoulder.
For months, she had believed the worst thing that had happened was that Xavier had chosen Bianca.
The deeper truth was more complicated and, in its way, more painful.
Xavier had not chosen Bianca over her.
Dex had chosen on their behalf.
But Xavier had given him the means to do it, and then failed to look.
The next morning, Xavier received a call from the authorities.
They had confirmed the identity of the man Dex described.
He was connected to an outside organization that had been collecting private information about the people around Xavier.
The authorities believed the group had been watching the penthouse and monitoring the building’s routines, but they did not yet know whether the information had been used to plan anything further.
Xavier shared the update with Phoebe before making any decisions.
“I don’t want this hidden from you,” he said.
“I appreciate that.”
“The authorities are handling the investigation.”
“Good.”
“Dex is cooperating through his attorney.”
“Good.”
“I won’t arrange anything on my own.”
Phoebe was quiet.
“Thank you for telling me before you acted.”
“I should have done that from the beginning.”
“Yes.”
He did not add that he wished he could undo it.
There was no way to make the past smaller by naming the regret.
Later, Xavier went to the penthouse bedroom and stood near the doorway.
The heels were gone, the wineglass long since removed, and the wall had been repainted after Phoebe left.
Still, he could picture her in the hallway, hearing Bianca’s voice and trying to decide whether opening the door would make her strong or only make the pain more undeniable.
He no longer wanted to know whether she should have asked him.
He wanted to understand why she had ever believed she couldn’t.
The security team called just before noon.
They had found one additional file in the old system, a short audio segment that had not been included in the first recovery because it was stored under a different date.
It was recorded several minutes before Bianca arrived.
Xavier played it once in the security office.
The sound was faint, but a familiar voice came through clearly.
Dex.
“Phoebe’s on her way back,” he said.
Then another voice answered.
A man Xavier did not recognize.
“Then you’d better make sure she sees enough to leave.”
Xavier stopped the recording.
The outside man had known Phoebe was coming home.
And someone inside the penthouse had told him.
**–END OF PART 4–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
* * *
[PREVIOUS: PART 3](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-3-the-footage-xavier-couldn-t-find-008) | [NEXT: PART 5](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-5-the-footage-xavier-couldn-t-find-008)