PART 12: The Bargain at Red Gorge
Rusk had trapped us between a damaged bridge and seven armed riders, but he had overlooked the fact that I knew the country surrounding Red Gorge better than he did.
My father had driven cattle through those hills long before Ward purchased his first acre in Bitter Creek.
There was an old livestock crossing downstream, narrow and difficult to reach but usable during low water.
I had inspected it only the previous summer.
While Rusk spoke, I moved closer to Ben and quietly told him where to find the trail.
He glanced toward the trees without turning his head.
Clara remained beside the wagon, one hand resting protectively on her father’s shoulder.
Rusk demanded that we surrender immediately.
I asked whether Ward had sent him to recover stolen papers or simply silence the people who knew too much.
His expression hardened at the question.
“You’ve made this worse than it needed to be, Carver.”
I told him that Matt might have said the same thing three years earlier.
Rusk’s hand tightened around his reins.
For the first time, I saw uncertainty beneath his practiced confidence.
I remembered Nathaniel saying that Rusk had fired the shot that killed my brother.
The knowledge pressed against my chest like a stone.
I wanted to drag him from the saddle and force him to answer for every day Matt had been missing from my life.
Instead, I thought about Clara, her father, and the injured man who had survived because people finally refused to abandon him.
I kept my revolver holstered.
Rusk watched me carefully, apparently disappointed that I had not given him an excuse to shoot.
I told him that the evidence had already been sent to the territorial authorities.
He laughed and said Ward had friends on every important road between Bitter Creek and Red Bluff.
I answered that messages traveled farther than riders could control.
While I spoke, Ben slowly guided the wagon toward the trees, pretending to turn it around.
Two of Rusk’s men followed his movement with their rifles.
I stepped farther into the road and shouted that I was the man they had come to punish.
Rusk turned his attention back to me.
He said Ward wanted me alive long enough to surrender the original survey and withdraw every allegation.
I asked whether Ward intended to pay me the same way he had paid Matt.
That question made Rusk dismount.
He walked toward me with his rifle held loosely across his chest.
“Your brother should’ve minded his own business.”
I felt my pulse pounding in my throat.
For a heartbeat, the world narrowed to the distance between his face and my hands.
Then Clara called my name from the wagon.
I looked toward her and remembered why I was standing there.
Behind her, Ben had reached the entrance to the hidden livestock trail.
One of the riders suddenly realized what was happening.
He shouted a warning, and several horses surged forward.
I fired into the ground before the nearest animals, sending them rearing backward.
Ben urged the wagon into the trees while Clara held Nathaniel steady.
A gunshot cracked from the ridge, striking the wooden signpost beside me.
I ducked behind a boulder as another bullet chipped stone near my shoulder.
Rusk shouted for his men to stop firing toward the wagon because Ward wanted Clara alive.
That hesitation gave Ben enough time to disappear down the narrow trail.
I mounted my horse and rode after them, drawing the pursuing riders away from the crossing.
The terrain narrowed into a rocky corridor where only one horse could travel comfortably at a time.
I knew an old passage through the hillside that would bring me back to the eastern road.
What I had not expected was the fresh barricade waiting at its entrance.
Two fallen trees blocked the path, and armed men emerged from behind the rocks.
My horse stumbled as I pulled hard on the reins.
Before I could turn, someone caught my arm and dragged me from the saddle.
I struck the ground hard enough to lose my breath.
Hands seized my shoulders, and a boot pinned my revolver beneath the dirt.
Rusk appeared above me moments later.
He looked toward the eastern hills, where Ben’s wagon had vanished.
“You helped them get away,” he said.
I spat dust from my mouth and told him that was the idea.
He struck me across the face with the back of his hand.
Then he ordered his men to bind my wrists.
I expected him to shoot me where I lay.
Instead, he pulled me upright and said Ward had other plans.
They took me west through the canyon until we reached an abandoned line shack near Stone Cut.
Inside, they tied me to a heavy support post and left one man guarding the door.
Rusk returned after sunset with a lantern and a piece of paper.
It was a statement declaring that I had fabricated the evidence against Ward and forced Nathaniel Hale to accuse innocent men.
If I signed, Rusk said, Ward would allow Clara and her father to leave the territory unharmed.
I asked what would happen to my ranch.
He shrugged and said I had already lost it.
I refused to sign.
Rusk studied me for a long moment before folding the statement.
“Then Ward will bring Clara here himself.”
I laughed bitterly and told him she would never return willingly.
Rusk approached until his face was inches from mine.
“She will when she learns what we’re going to do to you.”
He opened the door and called for the guard.
Then he gave an instruction that chilled me more than the threat itself.
“Tell Ward the prisoner is ready for Stone Cut.”